The stock market is a pretty complicated place, and unsolicited investing advice can be found seemingly everywhere. Yet that doesn’t mean it’s of high quality. That’s especially true when it comes to social media platforms, with many individuals advocating buying Russian mining stocks while their share prices are down. In my opinion, this investing advice is tragically flawed. Let me explain why.
Bad or good investing advice?
Evraz and Polymetal International are two of the largest mining businesses in the FTSE 100. Or at least they were, since both have now been removed from the index, and their respective share prices have plummeted by 73% and 92% in the last 12 months.
What happened? Well, both firms primarily operate within Russia’s borders. And with Western sanctions ramping up following the country’s invasion of Ukraine, these companies have been caught in the crossfire. So, it’s not surprising to see a massive sell-off from investors. But is this an over-reaction?
Should you invest £1,000 in ITM Power right now?
When investing expert Mark Rogers has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets. And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if ITM Power made the list?
That’s what some social media investing advice would suggest. After all, most of the extraction sites aren’t near the conflict. And with inflation, alongside demand for raw materials, skyrocketing, metal prices are going through the roof. So surely now would be an excellent time to buy these shares while they’re on discount?
That certainly seems like sound logic. But unfortunately, the situation is a bit more complicated.
Why I’m avoiding Russian mining stocks
This investing ‘advice’ is accurate in that most of the mining operations belonging to Evraz and Polymetal aren’t directly exposed to the ongoing crisis in Ukraine. However, indirectly, there’s a problem.
Mining is a notoriously capital-intensive process that often requires a heavy amount of external financing. This is typically secured through debt. But with sanctions cutting off the Russian banking system from SWIFT — an international payment & transaction network — securing such funding is becoming exceptionally challenging.
Evraz recently had trouble paying off its debt, not for lack of trying. An $18m bond coupon payment was blocked on Monday by the Office of Financial Sanctions Implementation (OFSI). The matter has since been resolved. But if the situation in Ukraine continues to escalate, future blocked payments to debt holders, creditors, or suppliers could create substantial problems for both of these businesses.
Both companies have large lumps of cash on their balance sheets, which should be enough to keep operations running throughout most of 2022. This liquidity is obviously an encouraging sight, given the situation. However, as things currently stand, the mid-to-long-term fate of these Russian mining businesses is being determined by external factors completely beyond managerial control. Hopefully, the situation in Ukraine will come to a quick and peaceful conclusion. But when will that happen is anyone’s best guess. In the meantime, these companies are being financially squeezed.
Personally, that’s not something I’m interested in adding to my portfolio. And it’s why I think such investing ‘advice’ is just plain awful. In my opinion, there are far more lucrative and less speculative investment opportunities for my portfolio elsewhere.
