The main takeaway I get from today’s half-year report from airline operator easyJet (LSE: EZJ) is that net cash from operations is down 40% compared to the equivalent period last year and the firm made an earnings-per-share loss of 5.1p, which compares to a profit of 1.3p per share last year.
No wonder, then, at 1,500p, the shares are down around 14% since the beginning of 2016. Whichever way we dress it up, this isn’t a good result for easyJet and the firm’s shareholders.
Precarious profits
The outcome here demonstrates what a precarious juggling act it is to keep an airline profitable and growing. During the period, easyJet faced pressure on its business from justifiably skittish customers due to travel strikes and terror attacks on European capitals.
Should you invest £1,000 in Petropavlovsk Plc right now?
When investing expert Mark Rogers has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the flagship Motley Fool Share Advisor newsletter he has run for nearly a decade has provided thousands of paying members with top stock recommendations from the UK and US markets. And right now, Mark thinks there are 6 standout stocks that investors should consider buying. Want to see if Petropavlovsk Plc made the list?
That’s the thing with an airline: we never know when a natural disaster such as an Icelandic volcano or man-made disasters such as war, conflict, strike, terrorism or commodity speculation will shoot down the firm’s profitability. But it gets worse than that. Airlines are also at the mercy of macroeconomic events making airline businesses and their shares among the most cyclical on the stock market.
That cyclicality has implications about how the market is likely to value businesses such as easyJet. The more mature a macro-cycle becomes, the lower I would expect easyJet’s valuation to be as the market tries to anticipate the next cyclical down-leg by discounting high earnings in the boom times.
Consumer demand strong
Right now, easyJet trades on a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of nine for the year to September 2017 and sports a twice-covered 4.7% dividend yield. I wouldn’t expect a higher valuation than that, so any further share price progress probably needs to come from business growth rather than from a valuation rerating.
Carolyn McCall, easyJet’s chief executive says: “easyJet has delivered a robust financial performance during the half year despite the well-publicised external events. Underlying consumer demand has been strong with UK beach traffic providing a healthy start to the half and easyJet’s biggest-ever ski season helping to deliver increased passenger numbers and higher revenue during H1.“
Okay. But it’s precisely when things are going at their best that we should expect a cyclical top, often followed by a descent into the next cyclical bottom. Nobody knows when the top will arrive, but I’m taking these first-half losses as a warning shot and now I’m avoiding easyJet shares.
A more robust business model
Pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline (LSE: GSK) enjoys a more robust business model than easyJet’s. The stable nature of demand for medicines makes GlaxoSmithKline’s operation far less cyclical and keeps the cash taps flowing as consumers repeat purchase drugs.
Sure, the pharmaceutical industry had its challenges over patent expiry issues as once high-earning formulations lost exclusivity in the market and the firm saw a flood of generic competition erode profits. However, the company is moving on from that and hopes a new generation of blockbusters will return the firm to enduring growth.
City analysts following the firm expect earnings to grow 16% this year and 4% during 2014. At today’s 1,475p share price GlaxoSmithKline trades on a forward P/E rating of just over 16 for 2017 and yields a dividend of 5.4% covered just over once by forward earnings. That’s a fair valuation for a defensive business with reasonable forward growth prospects.
